Equipment Lease vs Loan: Which is Better for Your Business?

Deciding between leasing or buying equipment is one of the most important financial decisions you'll make for your business. This comprehensive guide breaks down the pros, cons, tax implications, and total costs to help you make the right choice for your situation.

Equipment Lease vs Loan: Quick Comparison

What is an Equipment Loan?

An equipment loan (also called equipment financing) is a type of business loan where you borrow money to purchase equipment and pay it back over time with interest. The equipment itself serves as collateral, which means the lender can repossess it if you default on payments.

How Equipment Loans Work

1. Apply for financing based on the equipment cost
2. Get approved (typically in 24-72 hours)
3. Lender pays vendor directly for the equipment
4. You take ownership immediately
5. Make monthly payments over the loan term (1-10 years)
6. Own equipment outright once loan is paid off

Equipment Loan Pros

• Ownership from day one: Build equity with every payment
• Lower total cost: Pay less over time than leasing the same equipment
• Tax benefits: Deduct interest payments and depreciate the asset (Section 179 eligible)
• No usage restrictions: Use equipment however you want, no mileage or hour limits
• Asset on balance sheet: Increases net worth and borrowing capacity
• Can sell equipment: Recoup some costs if you no longer need it
• No end-of-term decisions: It's yours when paid off; no buyout negotiations

Equipment Loan Cons

• Higher monthly payments: Typically 20-40% more than lease payments
• Down payment required: Usually need 10-20% upfront
• You own the depreciation: Equipment loses value on your books
• Maintenance is your responsibility: All repair costs fall on you
• Technology risk: Stuck with equipment if it becomes obsolete
• Harder to upgrade: Must sell old equipment before buying new
• Impacts debt ratios: Shows as liability, may affect future borrowing

Best Situations for Equipment Loans

• Equipment with long useful life (10+ years)
• Essential equipment you'll use continuously
• When you want to build business assets and equity
• Industries with slow technology change (manufacturing, construction)
• When you need to maximize tax deductions through Section 179
• Stable businesses with predictable cash flow

What is an Equipment Lease?

An equipment lease is a rental agreement where you pay to use equipment for a specific period (lease term) without owning it. At the end of the lease, you can return the equipment, purchase it for fair market value or a predetermined price, or upgrade to newer equipment.

Types of Equipment Leases

1. Operating Lease (True Lease)

You rent equipment for less than its useful life and return it at lease end.

• Lease payments: 100% tax deductible as operating expense
• Balance sheet treatment: Off balance sheet (under certain conditions)
• End of lease: Return equipment, renew lease, or buy at fair market value
• Best for: Technology, vehicles, equipment needing frequent upgrades

2. Capital Lease (Finance Lease)

Structured more like a loan; you typically purchase the equipment at lease end for a nominal amount ($1 buyout common).

• Lease payments: Only interest portion is deductible
• Balance sheet treatment: On balance sheet as asset and liability
• End of lease: You own or have option to buy for minimal cost
• Best for: When you want eventual ownership but lower initial payments

Equipment Lease Pros

• Lower monthly payments: Typically 20-40% less than loan payments
• Minimal down payment: Often $0-1 payment down
• Preserve working capital: Keep cash for operations and growth
• Tax advantages: Operating lease payments are 100% deductible
• Easy upgrades: Get new equipment at lease end without selling old equipment
• Off balance sheet financing: Operating lease doesn't show as debt
• Maintenance included: Some leases include maintenance and repairs
• Technology hedge: Avoid obsolescence risk with short-term leases
• Easier approval: Less stringent qualification requirements

Equipment Lease Cons

• Never own equipment: No equity building (unless you buy at end)
• Higher total cost: Pay significantly more over time vs. buying
• Usage restrictions: May have hour, mileage, or usage limits
• Long-term obligation: Difficult and expensive to exit early
• End-of-lease charges: Fees for excess wear, damage, or overage
• Expensive buyout: Fair market value buyouts can be costly
• Must continue payments: Even if equipment breaks or you don't need it
• No Section 179 benefit: Can't take immediate depreciation deduction

Best Situations for Equipment Leases

• Technology that becomes obsolete quickly (computers, medical imaging, software)
• Seasonal businesses needing flexibility
• Startups preserving cash flow
• Testing equipment before committing to purchase
• Short-term projects (1-3 years)
• Businesses wanting to upgrade equipment regularly
• When maintaining a strong balance sheet is important (for loan covenants, etc.)

Cost Comparison: Lease vs Loan

Let's compare the total costs with a real example: A $100,000 piece of construction equipment over 5 years.

Equipment Loan Example

• Equipment cost: $100,000
• Down payment (15%): $15,000
• Loan amount: $85,000
• Interest rate: 8%
• Term: 5 years (60 months)
• Monthly payment: $1,724
• Total payments: $103,440 + $15,000 down = $118,440
• You own equipment worth ~$60,000 (resale value)
• Net cost: ~$58,440

Equipment Lease Example

• Equipment cost: $100,000
• Down payment: $0
• Lease rate: 10% (expressed as money factor)
• Term: 5 years (60 months)
• Monthly payment: $1,250
• Total payments: $75,000
• Fair market value buyout: $30,000 (if you want to own it)
• Total cost if purchasing: $105,000
• Or return equipment and owe nothing

The Verdict on Cost

In this example:

• If you plan to own long-term: The loan is cheaper (~$13,000 less) and you build equity
• If you want flexibility: The lease has lower monthly payments ($474/month less) and you can return equipment
• If you upgrade regularly: Leasing lets you get new equipment without selling; actual cost comparison depends on your upgrade cycle

Key Takeaway: Equipment loans are almost always cheaper in total cost if you plan to own the equipment for its full useful life. Leases offer flexibility and lower monthly payments but cost more over time.

Tax Implications: Lease vs Loan

Tax Benefits of Equipment Loans

Section 179 Deduction

When you buy equipment, you can potentially deduct the entire purchase price in year one:

• 2024 limit: $1,220,000
• Begins to phase out at $3,050,000 in equipment purchases
• Immediate tax benefit: Save 21-37% in taxes (depending on tax bracket) in year one
• Cash flow benefit: Large tax deduction reduces tax bill significantly

Bonus Depreciation

Additional first-year depreciation deduction:

• 2024: 60% of equipment cost
• Can combine with Section 179 for maximum benefit
• Phasing out: 40% in 2025, 20% in 2026, 0% in 2027

Interest Deduction

• Interest portion of loan payments is tax deductible
• Deducted as business expense
• Reduces taxable income throughout loan term

Tax Benefits of Equipment Leases

Operating Lease Deduction

• 100% of lease payments are immediately tax deductible
• Deducted as ordinary business expense
• Simpler than depreciation schedules
• Predictable deduction every year

Capital Lease Treatment

• Treated like a purchase for tax purposes
• Can depreciate the asset
• Only interest portion of payment is deductible
• Similar to loan treatment

Which is Better for Taxes?

It depends on your situation:

• Profitable businesses: Section 179 with equipment loan often provides largest immediate tax benefit
• Businesses with low/no taxable income: Leasing spreads deductions over time when you may be more profitable
• Businesses approaching Section 179 phase-out: Leasing may make sense
• Pass-through entities (S-corps, LLCs): Section 179 passes through to owners; large immediate benefit
• C-corporations: Either can work; depends on overall tax strategy

Consult Your CPA: Tax situations are highly individual. Always work with a tax professional to determine the best strategy for your specific situation.

Cash Flow Impact: Lease vs Loan

Equipment Loan Cash Flow

Pros:

• Own asset that appears on balance sheet
• Build equity with each payment
• No ongoing payments once loan is paid off
• Can sell asset for cash if needed

Cons:

• Larger down payment (10-20%) upfront
• Higher monthly payments reduce operating cash
• Maintenance costs are your responsibility
• Must continue payments even if business slows

Equipment Lease Cash Flow

Pros:

• Minimal to no down payment
• Lower monthly payments preserve working capital
• Predictable fixed costs for budgeting
• Some leases include maintenance (reduces surprise costs)

Cons:

• Never-ending payments if you keep leasing new equipment
• No equity building; all payments are expenses
• Can't stop payments even if you don't need equipment
• End-of-lease costs can surprise you

What Most Businesses Choose

• Established, profitable businesses: Usually choose loans to build assets and minimize long-term costs
• Startups and growing businesses: Often choose leases to preserve cash flow
• Seasonal businesses: May prefer leases for flexibility
• Technology-focused businesses: Often lease to stay current

Other Important Considerations

Qualification Requirements

Equipment Loan Requirements

• Credit score: 680+ preferred; 640+ possible
• Time in business: 2+ years typical
• Down payment: 10-20% usually required
• Documentation: Tax returns, bank statements, financials
• Personal guarantee: Almost always required

Equipment Lease Requirements

• Credit score: 600+ often sufficient
• Time in business: 1+ year may be acceptable
• Down payment: Often $0 down
• Documentation: Less extensive than loans
• Easier approval: Lessor retains ownership; less risk

Maintenance and Repairs

With Equipment Loan

• All maintenance is your responsibility
• All repair costs are yours
• You choose service providers
• Factor these costs into your budget
• Insurance is your responsibility

With Equipment Lease

• Depends on lease type and terms
• Full-service leases include maintenance
• Net leases make maintenance your responsibility
• Lessor may require specific service providers
• Insurance usually required; sometimes included

End-of-Term Considerations

Equipment Loan

• Equipment is yours when paid off
• Continue using at no additional cost
• Sell equipment when you're ready to upgrade
• No end-of-term inspections or fees

Equipment Lease

• Must decide: return, purchase, or renew
• Return: May face charges for excess wear/tear, usage overages, or damage
• Purchase: Pay fair market value (FMV) or predetermined amount
• Renew: Sign new lease, often on same or newer equipment
• Plan for these decisions 6-12 months before lease end

Industry-Specific Recommendations

Construction Equipment

Recommendation: Usually buy (loan)

• Heavy equipment has 10-20 year useful life
• Equipment holds value well if maintained
• Ownership builds equity
• Exception: Specialized equipment for short-term projects may warrant leasing

Medical Equipment

Recommendation: Depends on technology

• Imaging equipment (MRI, CT): Consider leasing due to rapid technology advancement
• Dental chairs, exam tables: Buy (loan) - long useful life
• Diagnostic equipment: Lease if technology changes quickly

Technology & Computers

Recommendation: Usually lease

• Becomes obsolete in 3-5 years
• Leasing allows easy upgrades
• Lower upfront costs for rapidly changing technology
• Exception: Standard office equipment may be worth buying

Manufacturing Equipment

Recommendation: Usually buy (loan)

• Core production equipment has long life (15-25 years)
• Technology changes slowly in most manufacturing
• Building assets strengthens balance sheet
• Can be sold or re-financed later if needed

Restaurant Equipment

Recommendation: Usually buy (loan)

• Commercial kitchen equipment lasts 10-15 years
• Technology changes slowly (ovens, refrigerators, etc.)
• Ownership is more economical long-term
• Exception: POS systems may warrant leasing

Transportation & Vehicles

Recommendation: Depends on use

• Delivery vans/trucks: Lease if you drive high miles (easier to upgrade)
• Semi-trucks for owner-operators: Buy (loan) to build equity
• Fleet vehicles: Many companies lease for flexibility and predictable costs
• Specialized vehicles: Buy if long-term use expected

How to Decide: Lease or Loan?

Ask yourself these questions:

1. How Long Will You Use This Equipment?

• 10+ years: Loan is almost always better financially
• 5-10 years: Loan usually better, unless cash flow is tight
• 3-5 years: Either can work; depends on other factors
• 1-3 years: Lease probably makes more sense

2. How Quickly Does This Technology Become Obsolete?

• Rapidly (1-3 years): Lease to stay current
• Moderately (5-7 years): Consider both options
• Slowly (10+ years): Buy and own long-term

3. What's Your Cash Flow Situation?

• Strong cash reserves: Can afford higher loan payments; buy
• Tight cash flow: Lower lease payments preserve working capital
• Growing business: Leasing preserves cash for growth investments
• Stable business: Buying builds equity and costs less long-term

4. What Are Your Tax Objectives?

• Need large deduction this year: Buy and take Section 179
• Expect higher profits in future: Lease to spread deductions over time
• Low taxable income: Either works; focus on cash flow

5. How Important Is Balance Sheet Strength?

• Need strong balance sheet (for lending, investors, etc.): Operating lease keeps debt off books
• Want to build assets: Loan puts valuable assets on balance sheet
• Debt covenants to maintain: Operating lease may help meet ratios

6. How Important Is Flexibility?

• Need to upgrade regularly: Lease for easy end-of-term transitions
• Want to own and control: Buy with loan
• Uncertain future needs: Lease provides more options
• Know exactly what you need long-term: Buy

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Focusing Only on Monthly Payment

The lowest monthly payment isn't always the best deal. Calculate total cost over the equipment's life, including end-of-lease buyouts, interest, and the value of ownership.

2. Not Reading Lease Terms Carefully

Understand:

• Usage limits (hours, miles, etc.)
• Early termination penalties
• End-of-lease options and costs
• Excess wear and tear charges
• Insurance and maintenance requirements

3. Ignoring Tax Implications

Tax benefits can significantly affect the true cost. Consult with your CPA before deciding to understand which option provides the best tax outcome for your situation.

4. Leasing Everything

While leasing preserves cash flow, leasing all equipment means you're never building equity. Consider a balanced approach: buy long-term core equipment, lease technology and vehicles.

5. Not Negotiating

Both lease and loan terms are negotiable:

• Interest rates and money factors
• Down payment amounts
• End-of-lease purchase options
• Usage allowances
• Early termination terms

6. Choosing Based on Approval Ease

Just because you can get approved for a lease more easily doesn't mean it's the right choice. Consider the long-term financial impact, not just the approval ease.

Hybrid Strategies

You don't have to choose one approach for all equipment. Many successful businesses use a hybrid strategy:

Buy Core Assets

• Production equipment
• Essential tools
• Equipment used daily
• Long-life equipment

Lease Everything Else

• Technology and computers
• Vehicles
• Specialized equipment used occasionally
• Equipment likely to need upgrades

Benefits of Hybrid Approach

• Build equity in core business assets
• Maintain flexibility for technology
• Balance cash flow needs
• Optimize tax benefits
• Reduce obsolescence risk where it matters

Real Business Example

Case Study: ABC Construction Company

The Situation:

• Needs to add an excavator ($150,000)
• Strong credit (710)
• $50,000 available for down payment
• Will use excavator for 10+ years
• Profitable; can use Section 179 deduction

The Options:

Option 1: Equipment Loan

• Down payment: $30,000
• Loan amount: $120,000 at 7% for 7 years
• Monthly payment: $1,913
• Total paid: $160,692 + $30,000 = $190,692
• Own equipment worth ~$75,000 after 7 years
• Net cost: ~$115,692
• Tax benefit: ~$33,000 in year one (Section 179)

Option 2: Equipment Lease

• Down payment: $3,000 (first payment)
• Lease payment: $3,000/month for 5 years
• Total paid: $180,000
• FMV buyout: ~$45,000 to own
• Total if buying: $225,000
• Tax benefit: ~$7,200/year spread over 5 years

The Decision: They Chose the Loan

Why:

• Will use excavator for 10+ years
• Loan costs $34,000 less if they buy out the lease
• Better tax benefits with Section 179
• Building assets improves balance sheet
• Equipment holds value well in construction

If ABC Construction needed computers or had tight cash flow, leasing might have made more sense. But for long-life core equipment, buying was the clear winner.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I switch from a lease to buying the equipment?

Yes, but typically only at the end of the lease term. Most leases include an end-of-lease purchase option at either fair market value (FMV) or a predetermined amount. Early buyouts are possible but usually require paying all remaining lease payments plus the residual value.

What happens if my business fails and I have an equipment loan or lease?

With a loan: You're obligated to repay the loan. If you default, the lender can repossess and sell the equipment. If sale proceeds don't cover the remaining balance, you may owe the difference (deficiency balance). Personal guarantees mean your personal assets are at risk.

With a lease: You're obligated to make all lease payments. If you default, the lessor can repossess the equipment and may charge early termination fees. You may also owe remaining lease payments. Personal guarantees are common here too.

Can I deduct a down payment on equipment?

For a loan, the down payment is part of the equipment purchase price and can be depreciated or deducted under Section 179 (if eligible). For a lease, the down payment (or cap cost reduction) is typically deducted over the life of the lease, not immediately.

Is equipment financing easier to get than other business loans?

Yes, generally. Because the equipment serves as collateral, lenders have less risk, making approval easier than unsecured loans. Equipment leases are even easier to qualify for since the lessor retains ownership.

Can I pay off an equipment loan early?

Usually yes, but check your loan agreement for prepayment penalties. Many equipment loans allow early payoff with no penalty, but some charge a fee (typically 1-5% of remaining balance). Always clarify this before signing.

What credit score do I need for equipment financing?

• Equipment loan: 640-680+ typically required; 700+ for best rates
• Equipment lease: 600+ often sufficient; easier approval than loans

Do equipment leases show up on my credit report?

Capital leases typically appear on your credit report as installment loans. Operating leases may or may not appear, depending on the lessor's reporting practices. However, defaults on either type will definitely appear and damage your credit.

Can I lease or finance used equipment?

Yes to both, but with some restrictions:

• Equipment typically must be less than 10 years old
• May require larger down payment
• Shorter terms available
• Equipment inspection often required
• Higher rates than new equipment financing

The Bottom Line: Which is Better?

There's no one-size-fits-all answer. The best choice depends on your specific situation:

Get Personalized Equipment Financing Quotes

Every business is different, and the right financing choice depends on your unique situation, equipment needs, cash flow, tax situation, and long-term goals.

Get matched with equipment financing specialists who can provide both loan and lease options. Compare rates, terms, total costs, and tax benefits to make an informed decision. Our service is free, fast, and connects you with lenders who specialize in your industry and equipment type.

Not sure what you need? Our lending partners can walk you through the numbers and help you understand which option makes the most financial sense for your business.